CAH2CLM: Classical Mythology - Assessment 3a: Essay Plan & Literature Review
History, Arts, and Linguistics
26th May 2025
2
CAH2CLM Classical Mythology
Assessment 3a: Essay Plan & Literature Review
Assessment 3a |
Essay Plan & Literature Review |
Due date |
11.59 pm (AEST/AEDT), Sunday 13 October 2024 (Week 10) |
Weighting |
15% |
Word count/length |
750 words |
SILOs |
Contextualise and analyse literary and material primary source evidence relating to ancient Greek and Roman mythology (SILO 1) Synthesise and interpret primary source evidence using disciplinary scholarship from Classics and Ancient History (SILO 2) Critique disciplinary scholarship and apply appropriate theoretical approaches in the context of interpreting ancient Greek and Roman mythology (SILO 3) |
Feedback |
Written feedback will be available 3 weeks from the due date. |
Purpose
Assessment 3 is divided into two parts. This first part requires you to write an essay plan and annotated bibliography.
This task is designed to help you begin researching, planning and writing the final essay. Completing the task should help you construct the central argument and identify what further research is required. You should use the feedback to check you are on the right track for the final essay.
Instructions
Choose one of the essay questions listed below. Make some notes and brainstorm to generate ideas for your essay then start doing some preliminary research. Once you feel you have a grasp of your topic, you’re ready to plan your essay.
Your plan should include:
Question you are answering
A brief thesis statement. This is your contention or what you intend to argue in the essay. Note that this requires you to come to a position. "I will examine/discuss..." is NOT a contention. "I will show/conclude that..." IS a contention. Think of the thesis statement as your one-sentence answer to the essay question.
Summary of the topics you will cover in the essay (aim for 4-5 key ideas) along with the main supporting evidence you will use for each topic. Here you should include which gods/heroes/families/myths you will analyse, and which sources you will draw on. This evidence can include primary or secondary source material.
Annotated bibliography of
3 secondary sources
you intend to use in the final essay. Format the bibliography in
Chicago style
, in alphabetical order by author’s surname. Your annotations should include a brief summary of the argument in the source, an evaluation of the strengths and limitations of the source and a reflection on how you will incorporate the source into your own argument.
Essay Questions
How did ancient Greeks and Romans explain the origins of the universe? In your answer you should compare the mythological tradition with other more ‘rational’ ways of explaining creation in Graeco-Roman antiquity.
How are Greek deities (gods and goddesses) reinterpreted and reutilised in Rome? In your answer, discuss at least three deities in detail.
Compare and contrast Greek and Roman heroism. In your answer discuss at least three heroes in detail.
How could mortal men and women win
kleos
(fame) in Greek myth? Would a woman’s path to
kleos
differ from a man’s and if so, why?
What do
ancient
accounts of the Underworld/Hades tell us about
Greek and Roman
ideas around death? In your answer discuss in detail at least three mythical figures connected with the Underworld.
‘One of the roles of heroes was to civilise the earth’. Discuss this statement with reference to three relevant myths – these could relate to the foundation of cities, the slaying of monsters, or another pertinent theme
.
Many
classical
myths
featur
e
family dynasties, from the Greek House of Atreus to the Roman kings. What do these myths tell us about ancient perceptions of familial roles and relationships?
In your answer discuss at least three figures from two
families.
Assessment Criteria
|
Excellent |
Very Good |
Good |
Satisfactory |
Unsatisfactory |
Question & Thesis Statement The essay question is indicated. The thesis statement clearly identifies the intended argument. The thesis statement directly addresses the issues raised in the essay question. |
|
|
|
|
|
Topics & Evidence: An appropriate range of topics are identified. An appropriate range of gods/heroes/families/myths are identified. Appropriate sources of primary and/or secondary evidence are identified. |
|
|
|
|
|
Secondary Source Choice Three relevant scholarly sources have been identified. |
|
|
|
|
|
Annotations The main argument/information in the sources has been identified. The annotations demonstrate how the source will be used in the essay. The strengths and weaknesses of the source for the essay been articulated. |
|
|
|
|
|
Writing The ideas are clearly communicated. The expression is fluent. The grammar, punctuation, spelling and other language conventions are correct. The tone is academic. |
|
|
|
|
|
Referencing & Instructions Referencing is thorough and all in-text citations and reference list follow the correct stylistic conventions. All other instructions followed. |
|
|
|
|
|
Submission details
Submit through the relevant submission link in the LMS Assessment block under Assessment 3.